Menu
Welcome to PeerMetals
Shop
HomeMarketplaceSpot DealsAuctionsSocial FeedCalculators & Tools
My Activity
Cart
My Account
Become a Seller
Support
Help CenterContact

Copyright © PeerMetals 2026

PeerMetals Help Center

Back to Help Center

Table of Contents

No headings found

Handling Disputes For Sellers

When a buyer reports a problem with an order, it opens a case. A case is a shared thread between you, the buyer, and PeerMetals support. Here's how to respond, how PeerMetals makes a decision, and what a case can cost you.


At a Glance

  • You'll get an email, and a red count appears on Cases in your Seller Hub.

  • Reply in the case within 24 hours. Cases without a reply go to PeerMetals support.

  • Add your evidence, such as tracking, photos, and receipts, as attachments in the case.

  • PeerMetals support issues refunds and return labels and makes the final decision.

  • Refunds and related costs can come out of your payouts or seller balance.


When a Buyer Opens a Case

  • Buyers can report a problem from their order page until the order is verified, either by the buyer or automatically 3 days after delivery.

  • At any time, they can report Item Not Received, a Shipping Problem, a Technical Issue, or Other Issue. After delivery, they can also report Wrong Item Received, Counterfeit or Fake Item, Item Damaged, Missing Items, or Quality Not As Described.

  • You'll get a New Support Case email with a Respond to Case button. You'll also get an email whenever the buyer or PeerMetals support posts in the case.

  • All your cases are on the Cases page in your Seller Hub, under the Active, Escalated, and Closed tabs. Click a case to open its thread.


Responding to a Case

  • Reply within 24 hours. Quick, clear replies resolve most cases before PeerMetals needs to step in.

  • Reply in the case thread, not in direct messages, so PeerMetals support can see the whole conversation.

  • Be specific and professional. Explain what you shipped, when, and how it was packed.

  • Attach your evidence: tracking details or the shipping label, photos of the item and the packed parcel, receipts, certificates, or grading details. You can attach images, PDFs, Word documents, or text files up to 5 MB, one file per message, with a short note.

  • Suggest a fair fix if one makes sense, such as a full or partial refund, a return, or reshipping a missing item. Say so in the case and PeerMetals support will carry it out. Sellers can't issue refunds or close cases themselves.

  • Lost, stolen, or damaged package? See Lost, Stolen & Damaged Packages for USPS searches, claims, and insured orders.


Escalation and the Final Decision

  • You or the buyer can click Escalate Case at any time and give a reason. This asks PeerMetals support to step in.

  • Cases are also escalated automatically when nobody replies within 24 hours, or sooner for items not received, counterfeit claims, and damaged items.

  • PeerMetals support reviews the thread and the evidence from both sides, decides the outcome, and closes the case. Please follow the decision.

  • If a buyer becomes abusive, don't argue. Escalate the case and let support take over.

  • Use Download Chat Log on the case page to keep a copy of the conversation.


What a Case Can Cost You

  • Payouts: PeerMetals may hold the payout for an order while it works to resolve the issue with the buyer. If the money has already been paid out to you, PeerMetals can deduct the amount from your seller balance or attempt to charge your bank or card on file.

  • Refunds: when a buyer gets a full or partial refund, the refunded amount comes out of your share of the sale.

  • Shipping labels: if an order is fully refunded after you bought the label, the label and any signature or insurance you added remain your cost.

  • Return shipping: who pays depends on what happened. When a return is your responsibility, PeerMetals support creates the return label and charges its cost to you.

  • Processing fee: if an order is cancelled because of something you did, the buyer gets the processing fee back and it's charged to you. See How Fees Work For Sellers.

  • Negative balance: anything you owe shows as a negative balance, and you'll need to clear it before you can withdraw. See Seller Penalties & Negative Balances.

  • Chargebacks: if a buyer disputes the payment with their bank instead, that's separate from a case. The order shows as On Hold on your Payments page until it's resolved.


Preventing Cases

  • Describe items accurately, with photos of the actual item and any flaws shown. See Listing Optimization Tips.

  • Ship on time with tracking, and pack securely. See Packaging & Shipping Insurance Guidelines.

  • Photograph the item and the packed parcel before you ship. It's your best evidence if a problem comes up.

  • Add insurance or signature confirmation on higher-value orders.

  • Keep buyers informed. Message them early about delays and answer questions quickly.


Need Help?

If you have questions about a case or our Buyer Protection Policy, start a live chat or visit our Contact Us page. Our support team is here to help!

Was this article helpful?

Handling Disputes For Sellers | PeerMetals Help Center