Menu
Welcome to PeerMetals
Shop
HomeMarketplaceSpot DealsAuctionsSocial FeedCalculators & Tools
My Activity
Cart
My Account
Become a Seller
Support
Help CenterContact

Copyright © PeerMetals 2026

PeerMetals Help Center

Back to Help Center

Table of Contents

No headings found

How To Spot Trusted Sellers

Most sellers on PeerMetals are honest collectors and dealers, and a little homework before you buy helps you shop with confidence. This article explains what to look for on a seller's profile and listings, the warning signs to watch for, and how to stay safe from scammers who pretend to be PeerMetals.


At a Glance

  • Check the seller's rating, reviews, sales, and join date.

  • Look for the green Verified User shield and the Sigma Verified badge on the seller's profile.

  • A negative Metal Points balance is a warning sign.

  • Always pay on PeerMetals. Buyer Protection doesn't cover payments made anywhere else.

  • PeerMetals will never ask you to verify your account through an outside link, or ask for your password or card details.


1. Check Ratings and Reviews

  • A seller's average star rating and number of reviews appear on their listings and on their profile.

  • Reviews can only be left by the buyer on an order, after the order is delivered, and each order can be reviewed once. That means every review comes from a real purchase.

  • Open the Reviews tab on the seller's profile to read what buyers said. Look for mentions of accurate descriptions, good packaging, and fast shipping.

  • A seller with many reviews and a high average rating has a proven history. A seller with no reviews isn't necessarily a problem, but it's worth taking a closer look.


2. Look for Badges

  • Verified User: A green shield next to the seller's name on their profile. Hover over it to see Verified User. It's given to members who have completed additional verification with PeerMetals or built a strong track record: more than 25 sales, or more than 15 purchases.

  • Sigma Verified: A green Sigma Verified badge on the seller's profile, and a Sigma Verified Seller note on their listings. It means PeerMetals has confirmed the seller owns a professional precious metals tester, such as a Sigma Metalytics device, to check their metals. It shows the seller has the tools to test what they sell, but it isn't a guarantee for each individual item.

  • Level badges: Round badges on a seller's profile for reaching Metal Points milestones (5,000, 15,000, and 50,000 points). Hover over a badge to see what it's for.


3. Check Their Metal Points

Metal Points are shown on every profile, on listings, and next to the seller's name on product cards. They reflect a member's activity on PeerMetals.

  • Members earn points for completed sales and purchases, new listings, and positive reviews.

  • Members lose points for negative reviews, unpaid auction wins, and offers they didn't follow through on.

  • A high balance usually means an active, established member. A negative balance means the member has lost points for problems like these, so be careful.

Learn more on the Metal Points page.


4. Look at Their Track Record

  • Join date: Profiles show when the member joined. Accounts created this month are labeled New Seller or New Buyer.

  • Sales and listings: The profile shows how many sales the seller has made and how many listings they have.

  • Followers: Established sellers often have a following of repeat buyers.


5. Review the Listing

  • Clear, original photos of the actual item, not just stock images.

  • A detailed description with weight, purity, year, mint, and condition.

  • A price that makes sense for the item. Compare it with the current spot price and similar listings.


6. Ask Questions

  • Message the seller through PeerMetals messages before you buy if anything is unclear.

  • Trusted sellers give clear, polite answers and are happy to share more photos.

  • Keep all of your conversations on PeerMetals. Messages on the platform can be reviewed by our team if there's ever a problem with an order.


7. Watch for Red Flags

  • Requests to pay outside PeerMetals, such as Zelle, Venmo, PayPal, Cash App, wire transfer, gift cards, or sending crypto directly. Payments outside PeerMetals aren't covered by Buyer Protection.

  • Requests to move the conversation to email, text, or another app.

  • Prices that are too good to be true, such as gold or silver listed well below spot price.

  • Stock photos only, or vague and inconsistent descriptions.

  • Pressure to act fast, such as "pay in the next hour or the deal is gone."


8. Protect Yourself from PeerMetals Impersonators

Scammers sometimes send emails or messages that pretend to come from PeerMetals or Stripe. These often say your account or sales will be put on hold unless you "verify" something right away.

PeerMetals will never:

  • Ask you to verify your account, confirm an order, or unlock a sale through a link to an outside site, Google Doc, or Google Drive file.

  • Ask for your password, full card number, or bank login in a message or email.

  • Ask you to pay for anything outside of PeerMetals.

How to stay safe:

  • Only sign in at peermetals.com. Watch for lookalike website addresses.

  • Real Stripe emails come from stripe.com. If you're unsure about one, check your account on PeerMetals instead of clicking the link.

  • When a message contains a link to another website, PeerMetals warns you with a "You're leaving PeerMetals" screen before it opens. Links that imitate PeerMetals are blocked and shown as "Dangerous link blocked."

  • Not sure if something is real? Ask us through live chat on our Contact Us page before you click anything.

  • If you already clicked a suspicious link or entered your details, change your PeerMetals password right away and contact support.


9. Report and Block

  • Report a user from the menu on their profile or in your conversation with them. Choose a reason such as Fraud or Scam or Impersonation.

  • Report a listing with the Report button on the listing page, for example if you think an item is counterfeit or misleading.

  • Block a user from their profile or your conversation with them to stop them from contacting you.

Our team reviews every report. When we find scam accounts, we remove them and their messages.


Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Can I trust a new seller with no reviews?

A: Many new sellers are perfectly reliable. Take a closer look at their listings, ask questions before you buy, and always pay through PeerMetals so your order is covered by Buyer Protection.

Q: How does PeerMetals check sellers?

A: Sellers go through identity verification with our payment partner, Stripe, when they sign up to sell. Our team also reviews reports from the community and watches for suspicious activity, such as requests to pay outside the platform.

Q: What if I receive a fake or counterfeit item?

A: Report it from your order page within 3 days of delivery using Report a Problem. Counterfeit items are covered by our Buyer Protection Policy.

Q: What should I do if I'm unsure about a seller?

A: Message the seller with your questions, or contact our support team through live chat. We're happy to help.


Need Help?

If you have questions about a seller, or think you've been contacted by a scammer, start a live chat or visit our Contact Us page. Our support team is here to help!

Was this article helpful?

How To Spot Trusted Sellers | PeerMetals Help Center